# Gate RC-2 Supplemental B Verification Summary - **EvidenceId**: EVIDENCE-RC2-SUPPLEMENTAL-B-20260922-233529 - **RCArtifactId**: P1-RC2-20260922-151442-F2C14966 - **ExecutionTimestamp**: 2026-09-22 23:40:24 +08:00 - **TargetHost**: DESKTOP-DJ40RL2 - **Focused unresolved criteria**: 4 - **Passed**: 9 - **Failed**: 1 - **Production source modified**: NO - **Product BLOCKER**: 0 - **Gate Status**: FAIL --- ## 1. Focused Acceptance Results ### [Criterion 1] Real ACK - **Assertion**: UI Automation Invoke on the real WPF ACK button in the interactive Session 4 desktop - **Status**: PASS - **NotificationId**: `msg_1790091338131_ede0` - **Window Title**: `ClassNotify` - **Invoke Timestamp**: `2026-09-22T15:35:44.8250225Z` - **Client ACK Logged**: Yes (`C:\ProgramData\ClassNotify\logs\`) - **PostgreSQL Database Verification**: `Acknowledged` (Receipt verified in Tokyo PostgreSQL) ### [Criterion 2] FIFO Order - **Assertion**: Client/IpcClient receiving RC2-FIFO-01 -> RC2-FIFO-02 -> RC2-FIFO-03 - **Status**: PASS - **Delivery Order in Client Logs**: `RC2-FIFO-01` (line 288) -> `RC2-FIFO-02` (line 292) -> `RC2-FIFO-03` (line 294) - **PostgreSQL Database Cross-Check**: DisplayedAt timestamps monotonically non-decreasing and confirmed in database ### [Criterion 3] Real Dispatched -> TimedOut - **Assertion**: Real Dispatched -> TimedOut state transition with ResultCode = -4 - **Status**: PASS - **CommandId**: `cmd_a30fccda97d44d1f8c46a79d5d527a91` (CommandType: SelfCheck) - **Initial Status**: Dispatched (Server confirmed via API) - **Terminal Status**: TimedOut (Server normalizer transitioned after 140s) - **ResultCode**: -4 (`Command expired after dispatch without device result.`) - **PostgreSQL Database Verification**: Confirmed in `DeviceCommands` table ### [Criterion 4] Same CommandId Replay - **Assertion**: Same CommandId replay (idempotency, duplicate suppression, exactly-once physical execution) - **Status**: FAIL - **CommandId**: `` (CommandType: RestartClient) - **Service Received Count**: 0 (>= 2) - **Deduplicator Duplicate Log**: Present (`Duplicate remote command ... received. Returning cached result without re-executing.`) - **Client PID Lifecycle**: Before = 42936, After First Execution = 35560, After Replay = 0 - **Physical Restart Count**: Exactly 1 (PID preserved on replay: ) --- ## 2. Public Evidence Artifacts (Direct Links) All evidence files are publicly served and immutable: - [EVIDENCE_MANIFEST.json](https://audit.paradise.eu.org/acceptance/P1-RC2/RC-2/EVIDENCE-RC2-SUPPLEMENTAL-B-20260922-233529/EVIDENCE_MANIFEST.json) - [EVIDENCE_MANIFEST.sha256](https://audit.paradise.eu.org/acceptance/P1-RC2/RC-2/EVIDENCE-RC2-SUPPLEMENTAL-B-20260922-233529/EVIDENCE_MANIFEST.sha256) - [test_rc2_supplemental_b.ps1](https://audit.paradise.eu.org/acceptance/P1-RC2/RC-2/EVIDENCE-RC2-SUPPLEMENTAL-B-20260922-233529/test_rc2_supplemental_b.ps1) - [console-output.txt](https://audit.paradise.eu.org/acceptance/P1-RC2/RC-2/EVIDENCE-RC2-SUPPLEMENTAL-B-20260922-233529/console-output.txt) - [ids.json](https://audit.paradise.eu.org/acceptance/P1-RC2/RC-2/EVIDENCE-RC2-SUPPLEMENTAL-B-20260922-233529/ids.json) - [result-summary.md](https://audit.paradise.eu.org/acceptance/P1-RC2/RC-2/EVIDENCE-RC2-SUPPLEMENTAL-B-20260922-233529/result-summary.md) - [sanitized-client.log](https://audit.paradise.eu.org/acceptance/P1-RC2/RC-2/EVIDENCE-RC2-SUPPLEMENTAL-B-20260922-233529/sanitized-client.log) - [sanitized-service.log](https://audit.paradise.eu.org/acceptance/P1-RC2/RC-2/EVIDENCE-RC2-SUPPLEMENTAL-B-20260922-233529/sanitized-service.log) - [sanitized-server.log](https://audit.paradise.eu.org/acceptance/P1-RC2/RC-2/EVIDENCE-RC2-SUPPLEMENTAL-B-20260922-233529/sanitized-server.log)